CPA Letter to Senators Regarding China Section 301 Tariff Exclusions

CPA sent the following to U.S. Senators Rob Portman (R-OH), Tom Carper (D-DE), and 38 other members of the Senate regarding their recent letter to Ambassador Tai asking her to renew expired expiring China Section 301 tariff exclusions. In the letter, CPA urges the Senators to reconsider their support for renewing 301 exclusions, an action that would be contrary to America’s national and economic security interests.

Dear Senator Portman:

The Coalition for a Prosperous America (CPA) writes regarding your recent letter to Ambassador Tai asking her to renew expired and expiring China Section 301 tariff exclusions.

CPA is thankful that you recognize the problems with China’s trade practices. But we also urge you to reconsider your support for renewing 301 exclusions, an action that would be contrary to America’s national and economic security interests. The primary winners in 301 exclusions are the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), Chinese manufacturers and DC law firms while it’s the American people and our national interests who lose – jobs and national security are just two examples – if these exclusions are continued.

The basis for the tariffs is the unparalleled, state-sponsored theft of intellectual property used as a core growth strategy by Beijing which threatens American’s national security and interests. The 301 report documented systematic joint venture requirements and licensing requirements designed to force the transfer of core technology from American to Chinese companies. It also revealed cyber-hacking, weaponized incoming investment and many other acts and practices in Beijing’s multi-pronged toolbox to steal technology.

The CCP has not apologized or stopped those acts and practices. Instead it retaliated with tariffs, engaged in genocide, annexed Hong Kong, and increased military pressure on Taiwan among other actions. FBI Director Christopher Wray told the Senate Intelligence Committee this month that the FBI opens an investigation that ties back to the Chinese government every 10 hours.

A blanket renewal of exclusions would reward China, showing that America is not serious about confronting its IP theft, its genocide, and its military aggression. It would suggest that America does not care about national security. And it would prove that America cares more for multinational corporate profits than rebuilding supply chains and creating good jobs in America.

U.S. businesses have had four years since the start of the 301 investigation to relocate supply chains outside of China. There has been sufficient time for businesses to modify their supply chains. Many businesses have moved production or procurement back to the United States to employ more U.S. workers. Others have moved production to third countries. CPA’s review of the most recent exclusions (granted October, 2020) finds that in many instances, the petitioning businesses are openly saying that they have considered and rejected sourcing from outside China. They evidently expect their exclusions to be permanent and ongoing.

The 301 exclusions are not designed to be a permanent exception favoring private profit interests which run counter to our national interests. Simply put, as we approach the four-year anniversary of the start of the China 301 investigation, any business that has been unable to source components from anywhere in the world outside of China is either not trying or is not competent.

Our Founding Fathers transformed our country from an agrarian colony to the biggest industrial economy in the world less than 100 years after the American Revolution with gritty determination to build new supply chains here. Now, as we face the prospect of ceding global leadership to an authoritarian adversary, policy leaders must be firm in meeting the challenge to rebuild our country’s industrial might rather than serving the interests of stateless multinationals.

We stand ready to work with you in this regard.

Thank you,

Zach Mottl, Chairman

Michael Stumo, CEO


CPA is the leading national, bipartisan organization exclusively representing domestic producers and workers across many industries and sectors of the U.S. economy.

The latest CPA news and updates, delivered every Friday.


Get the latest in CPA news, industry analysis, opinion, and updates from Team CPA.